“You are an island.” This poetical sentence is originally intended to highlight the character of a lone warrior. However, who claimed that this island is uninhabited? Just think of the large amount of microbial symbionts you are hosting on and in your body. You are a sort of island for them. You are the world for them. So even the loneliest warrior is not lonely at all. In fact, you will never be completely alone. This knowledge about the colonies of microorganisms for example on our skin or in our gut seduces us to think that this is sort of a rule for any larger organism. So it doesn’t make sense to study any animal alone, but you need to understand the animal as “holobiont”, as host plus its microbiome, because just the interplay between the commensal, pathogenic, and mutualistic microorganisms and their host make the host to what it seems to be… a rabbit, a dog, a human,… . The usage of antibiotics, which damage our gut microbiome, shows perfectly how much our health is connected to these little gut inhabitants. Many organisms show developmental disorders if there is something wrong with their gut microbiome. Many organisms… not all! Caterpillars doesn’t have a gut microbiome. This is the message of the paper from Tobin J. Hammer et al. (2017). Gut microbiome analyzation of 124 different species (15 different families) of wild leaf-feeding caterpillars in the United States and Costa Rica showed that Lepidoptera (butterflies) had gut bacterial densities multiple orders of magnitude lower than the microbiomes of other insects. Moreover, the majority of the small amount of gut bacteria which could be found in the guts of caterpillars, were leaf-associated bacteria. They didn’t live in the gut but were more transient visitors because their original home was eaten. So caterpillars seem not to depend on a gut microbiome which help them to digest the plant parts. Indeed, treatment with antibiotics didn’t affected the growth and development of the caterpillar. In contrast, in the laboratory, it actually increases growth because it kills pathogenic microorganisms. So we may should correct our idea that all organisms are like us: large hosts which life and health are connected to millions of small symbionts. Walking sticks, sawfly larvae and certain ants as well as a herbivorous goose (Branta bernicla) and a insectivorous bat (Myotis lucifugus) all these species are known for showing low fecal bacterial loads comparable to the caterpillars. They all seem to resign the additional digest help of gut bacteria in order to get more energy out of their food and instead focus on a sort of “more is more” strategy. They all have short guts with rapid digestive transit (so high feeding rate). So even if they don’t get much out of a single portion of food, they compensate this by eating a lot. This has the benefit that they can keep all nutrients for themselves, as the don’t have to “pay” the gut bacteria for their work, and they are maybe more flexibel what they can eat, as they just have to satisfy their own taste and not the taste of one million gut inhabitants. "Caterpillars lack a resident gut microbiome."
Tobin J. Hammer, et al. (2017) PNAS, doi:10.1073/pnas.1707186114
0 Kommentare
Hinterlasse eine Antwort. |
IdeaI love to increase my general science knowledge by reading papers from different fields of science. Here I share some of them. Archiv
März 2018
Kategorien
Alle
|